The Baba Ramdev factor and the crisis of ideas

“We need to follow the Chinese example of shooting dead the people found guilty of corruption”

“Homosexuality is a ‘disease’ and it can be cured through yoga. It is a virus and once it effects the person can go nowhere”.

“Actress such as Celina Jaitley know nothing about Bhartiya sanskriti because they always stay away from parents and have no morals”.(Celina Jaitley supports Gay rights)

“The extent of black money in the country is Rs 30,000,000 crore(!!!). The government should recall all currency in circulation and issue a new one — all unaccounted money will fall into its hands”.

“Our law says that not one innocent should be punished, even if a hundred guilty go free. We should see to it that all guilty get punished; if that includes one or two innocent, so be it.”

“Government needs to fix prices of all goods and services managed by Private enterprises and, thereby, control profits! I know most large businessmen and what kind of obscene money companies make”.

“Bollywood actors are characterless. These are the dark ages, as now our children look up to these singing and dancing females as icons. In our times they were known as Bhand the person who dances for money, now these people have become stars of Bollywood. Also they are not big actresses but rotten actresses. They change partners with every film they do”.

“A minimum qualification criteria should be fixed to stop everyone from becoming a “baba” and death sentence should be awarded to “fraud” religious gurus indulging in wrongdoings in the garb of religion”.
— Baba Ramdev’s words of wisdom

All the above statements are made by the man of the moment— RamKishan Yadav aka Baba Ramdev.

Here is the man whose views on issues from homosexuality to private enterprise are so retrograde that even his followers would find it horrifying. But all of them seem to have taken a deep breath and preferred to overlook his retrograde views and concentrate on his present obsession, fighting against black money and corruption.

Is there anyone in this country or anywhere else who dare say, we are for black money and corruption? But despite no one being in favour of it, why has this practice not stopped or rather escalated over the years? Simple. Greed. Greed is the root-cause of corruption which in turn generates black money, which lands up in foreign banks and surely in Haridwar also. And does Ramkishan Yadav have a cure for it, from any of the asanas he purveys?

He obviously doesn’t have a miracle cure tucked away even in his tens of crores worth Ashram in Haridwar or any of the multi-crore Food Parks. So what does he do? He decides to sit on a fast unto death in the nation’s capital. But then he does not say when he seeks permission, that he is going to do it. He says he will hold a Yoga camp and therefore needs the Ramlila grounds. Police and authorities are foxed, they know his real intentions, but can’t presume anything and have to give him permission when the official reason he gives is a Yoga camp. If they had presumed and denied permission, he and the media would have bludgeoned the authorities for denying permission for a perfectly legitimate activity.

The UPA Government is flummoxed. After the badgering they got when Kisan Baburao Hazare aka Anna Hazare and his bandwagon had held the fast a few weeks back in the capital, they did not want to be seen as indifferent again. So what do they do? They go overboard. They rush four ministers and the Cabinet Secretary and his appointed successor to the airport to hold talks. Apparently the plan was to hold talks there and if they don’t succeed in convincing Ramdev aka Ramkishan Yadav to withdraw his plans for a fast, they would pack him off from the airport. But despite him not agreeing to them, they lose the nerve to pack him off, and in the bargain come out looking like a bunch of defeated soldiers from a war. They also in turn earn all kinds of sobriquets, none of which any of them would even like to remember in their wildest nightmare. The Government also comes out it in poor light and rightly so.

Having been subjected to such an extra-ordinary treatment at the airport, remember not even the US President or the Queen of England gets four senior Cabinet ministers welcoming them at the airport, Ramdev aka Ramkishan Yadav thinks he can play around with the Government now. As his followers troop in from different parts of the country and start gathering at the Ramlila Maidan, he starts feeling that he has already conquered the Capital, his ultimate aim incidentally.

The Government however does not give up. It molly coddles him with responses which even an MP cannot expect on the floor of the parliament, with such alacrity. They bring out a laundry list of issues raised by him and agree to most of it. The political juvenility of it is evident to all, but the Government. The Ministers and those advising them think that they can turn the tables on the physically dexterous Ramdev aka Ramkishan Yadav, with their politically dexterous moves.

They even get him to give them a shabbily hand-written letter promising to end the so-called fast unto death. Ramdev aka Ramkishan Yadav drunk with the media-glare he has been enjoying for last 48 hours, thinks he can hoodwink the Government for some more time and enjoy the national media attention he is getting. He gets exposed, as by then the Government had enough of mollycoddling him and decides to be tough. One mistake has led to another, and late in the night it leads to one more.

Troops of security forces troop into Ramlila Maidan declares the permission granted is revoked and asks Ramdev aka Ramkishan Yadav to vacate. They resist. He even shows his simian abilities when he jumps from the stage and disappears into a mass of women and then tries to escape disguised as one of them. Though how he thought he could hide his beard in that white salwar and kurta, one can only guess. He is discovered and hustled off to the airport. Meanwhile his enraged supporters indulge in brickbats with police and women even assault policemen. Like all police forces all over do, they employ rough tactics to clear them, and even fire teargas shells. But unlike what happened in Nandigram or in many other places, they display restraint, and cause minimum harm, despite the potential for larger damage.

BJP and some other parties as well as many other people with new found fame, clog the traditional media as well as the social media with chants evoking memories of Jalianwala Bagh and Emergency. They start smelling an issue which they have been desperately searching for long. All hell breaks loose and sense of proportion seems to have become a major casualty.

Meanwhile the femininely attired Ramdev aka Ramkishan Yadav who is safely escorted back to his five-star ashram in Haridwar is found in a daze and later breaks down several times as he addresses his followers and the media, but later recovers to declare that his fast will continue, although in the safer confines of his ashram. We are all left to wait for some more melodrama and pious proclamations in the coming days.

Meanwhile, the Congress party goes into a huddle. It is sad to see that though Congress is only one, though the leading party, in the UPA Government, it has decided to handle both the Hazare and Ramdev issue as if it is only a Congress issue. Such seasoned politicians in the alliance like Sharad Pawar, M.Karunanidhi, even Lalu Yadav(who supports the government officially) are kept away and are not even consulted. Even seasoned politicians within the Congress party are kept at bay. All wisdom to handle such issues seems to be the sole prerogative of a few in the Congress party. And the results are there for all to see.

As for the question why people like Ramdev aka Ramkishan Yadav with rather dubious reputations and the rather naïve Anna aka Kisan Baburao Hazare, have gained such unprecedented civil society approval is concerned, the answer is simple— the failure of the politicians of all hue and colours to respond to the aspirations and frustrations of the common man. The sooner the politicians realize this and make amends, the better it is for a parliamentary democracy. Otherwise what we will have is autocracy of the newly discovered heroes, with questionable understanding, retrograde ideas and worse impatient agendas and ambitions, encouraged by a breathless media unable to fathom the long-term damage it is causing to the body politic of this country.

Share
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

12 Responses to “The Baba Ramdev factor and the crisis of ideas”

  1. rajaram says:

    The naive approach to a serious issue shows how individuals run campaigns more on emotion rather then on a clear legitimate path. There is no dearth of eminent lawyers and P R agency to guide.There is no lack of resources! Yet one goes about such programs smacking of astute and serious approaches.A program of this magnitude without a contingency plan shows an immature d undertaking and demeaning a nations trust.Yhr citizens are the biggest losers in their quest.

  2. shreesha says:

    A piece well written. Unfortunately, when elected reps behave as though they cannot be questioned of any wrong doings,any person with capacity to gather even few hundreds become a hero. Issues of Tackling corruption and bringing corrupt to book (however powerful he/she may be) is what India needs for good governance. Govt scampers to put some system in place in a couple of days (when threatened with mass agitation), what it has failed to do for decades. It is amusing to see Parties’ reactions along the alliance grouping, though the issue is common and should be (maybe already) a part of election Manifesto of all political parties!
    It is not understandable, how state can get scared of even minor dissidence and goes overboard in it’s reactions. Hazare and Ramdev have redefined silent agitation of masses against the Rulers–letus hope that it acts as a wake up call to all political parties to take care of their Masters’ (people) needs.

    The media is the winner always with sufficient content for running their channel for one whole week!!

  3. Jarpum Gamlin says:

    Baba Ramdev’s words of wisdom says it all!

    His antics, while in Arunachal Pradesh, took many of his followers by surprise too. Leave him at that. He doesnot deserve so much of space as political activist. He should focus on his core-competency as a Yog (that’s how I prefer to pronounce) Guru

  4. Dr.B.Devadas Baliga says:

    Totally agree nobody wants to give bribe voluntarily unless he wants to do something illegally. Also agree that most of what he demanded makes no sense, except confiscating the ill gotten wealth kept abroad.

    Toally opposed to raid on unarmed decent men/women sleeping in the pandal.Is there a single police been attacked/ injured/hospitalised? I have not seen on the extensive and oringly repeatitive TV coverage.

  5. I.Ramamohan Rao says:

    Thanks Girish,

    The way media was giving attention to the Baba was scandalous.

    Thank God he was thrown out.

    It is time Civil Society members, who crave for publicity, also are put in their places.

    ramamohanrao

  6. atul KT says:

    Girish
    Your piece makes a hilarious reading. although I would not despair so readily, the whole political establishment needs to get its acts together to take advantage of drifting of governance in India. Very difficult to predict where all this is leading to. Charlatans within and outside the government. You may delve deeper into the causes of such a ludicrous turn of events. It is more than mere politics. It’s like flower years of 1970s when many factors combine to create wobbly gait of our democratic system. We are not able to see clearly because we are not able to understand what is happening to us.
    At one level, its is Anna’s jholawala brigade in jeans and kurta–consumerised, titillated by media, unable to locate itself within the electoral system yet willing to contribute to debate, with simplistic solutions, like sms-ing without realising the significance of mobile telephony. At another level, we have swami jis, of all hues, trying to come under a common umbrella, with catchy controtions of tummy muscles and naive optimism of spiritual kinds. Both following Gandhian stayagraha! While the naxalites infest our jungles, such mavericks are urbanised nihilists, with a mishmash of ideas on environment, self-medication, benefits of liberalisation, obscene Hindi songs, lurid imaginations of perversity of political classes; each adherent purer in its estimation than the guy next.
    Is it all because of so many changes so rapidly in such a short time that we are not able to internalise the imprints on our cognition, leading to wayward behaviour? ….
    Atul

  7. shubho says:

    Great piece Girish
    shubho

  8. poornananda DS says:

    This Baba appears to be a fraud but he has every right to protest peacefully. By mishandling the situation the government has made him a hero. Four ministers running to airport to placate the donghi baba was ridiculous. Those who demand summary execution of offenders cannot be members of “civil” society. All civil society members should keep off this Baba. He has bigger plans beyond fighting corruption. People of questionable integrity will weaken the movement against corruption.

  9. jothindra says:

    The Central Government was right in its decision to close the Baba Ramadev Show. As someone rightly said in the news, “Democracy doesn’t mean that some Tom, Dick and Harry hold a gun to the temple of the Government every now and then.” And also, he had committed in writing that he would conclude his show in the afternoon itself. But I don’t know what would have happened had the small fire spread and brought the pandal down.

    There was something amateurish, (clownish?) about Baba Ramadev jumping off the stage and hiding in women’s clothes,was’nt it? And his statements are sometimes juvenile too.

    I hope he has learnt his lesson!

  10. Krish says:

    You can ridicule Ramdev or Hazare to your heart’s content but you cannot deny that the fifty thousands who came to Ramlila Ground to support Ramdev on 4th June were concerned with only one issue i.e. how the daily harassment they face at the hands of the lowliest of govt functionaries(they can’t even imagine that they can get access to the high and mighty)can be lessened.So it will be appreciable if you expand your intellectual energy on compelling the govt to help these hapless crores.

  11. Pk says:

    You have quoted some Babaji’s statements, which your readers would think verbatim. but they are not. You would have to add link to sources (pref: video of swami ji saying this), otherwise dont selectively pick words and weave a story around without understanding the context in which the words were said.

  12. Banjagere Jayaprakash says:

    It is nice to read a balanced analysis of the melodramas blowing false hopes of rectification for the faults in the system. Thank you Girish.

Leave a Reply

 
Powered by WordPress | Free T-Mobile phones at BestInCellPhones.com. | Thanks to Verizon Wireless, Facebook Games and The diet solution